
- SNT-TC-1A is a recommended practice, applied through an employer's written practice that sets the detailed requirements.
- ANSI/ASNT CP-189 is a standard with mandatory requirements, leaving the employer less room to vary them.
- The governing code, edition and client specification often decide the route, so check them before building a programme.
- ISO 9712 offers central, third-party certification and is required by some clients and jurisdictions instead.
An NDT contractor wins a new client and discovers that its technicians' certifications, valid for years on other work, do not meet the specification. The client's documents call for certification to a different scheme, or ask for evidence that the existing written practice cannot provide. Technicians are stood down while paperwork is rebuilt, and the project starts late.
This happens because "certified NDT technician" can mean several different things. The route by which a person is certified affects what an employer must document, what examinations are needed and which clients will accept the result. Choosing the route deliberately, rather than inheriting it, avoids most of these surprises.
SNT-TC-1A: a recommended practice
ASNT's Recommended Practice No. SNT-TC-1A provides guidelines for employers to establish their own programme for qualifying and certifying NDT personnel. It is not mandatory in itself. Instead, the employer writes a written practice that adopts the guidance, adapts it to its own work and sets the detailed requirements for training, experience, examinations and recertification.
The strength of this route is flexibility. The employer can tailor requirements to its methods and clients. The weakness is that the quality of the programme depends entirely on the written practice and on how faithfully it is followed. Certification is issued by the employer, and it generally applies to work for that employer.
CP-189: a standard
ANSI/ASNT CP-189, the Standard for Qualification and Certification of Nondestructive Testing Personnel, sets minimum requirements that are mandatory for organisations that adopt it. Certification is still employer-based, but the employer has less freedom to vary the requirements, and the standard sets specific expectations for the Level III, including holding ASNT NDT Level III certification. Training content is linked to the topical outlines in ANSI/ASNT CP-105.
CP-189 tends to produce more consistent programmes across organisations, at the cost of less room to adapt. Some clients and codes prefer it for exactly that reason.
The right certification route is the one your governing documents actually call for.
What clients and codes may require
The choice is often made for you. Construction codes, in-service inspection codes, client specifications and contracts may reference SNT-TC-1A, CP-189 or a central certification scheme, and the specific edition referenced matters because requirements change between editions. Some clients add their own conditions, such as minimum experience for particular techniques or additional practical demonstrations.
Before building or changing a programme, collect the documents that govern your work and read what each one actually requires. Where requirements differ between clients, your written practice or certification arrangements need to satisfy the most demanding one that applies to each person.
Documentation, examinations and experience
Whichever route you follow, auditors will expect a clear trail for each certified individual. The essentials are consistent across schemes:
- Training records: course content, hours and provider, mapped to the requirements of the chosen route.
- Experience records: verifiable evidence of method-specific work, signed by a responsible person.
- Examinations: general, specific and practical results, with records of who set, administered and graded them.
- Vision tests: current results meeting the requirements of the written practice or standard.
- Certification statement: the employer's certification, signed and dated, stating method and level.
The required training hours, experience periods and pass marks differ between documents and editions, and under SNT-TC-1A they are defined in the employer's written practice. Take them from the governing document rather than from memory or habit.
Recertification principles
Certification is not permanent. Each route defines a recertification interval and what is needed to renew, which may include evidence of continued satisfactory work, re-examination or both. Certification can also lapse when a person leaves the employer or stops working in the method for a defined period. Track these dates centrally, since an expired certificate discovered during an audit is an avoidable finding.
Where ISO 9712 fits
ISO 9712 takes a different approach. Certification is granted by an independent certification body rather than by the employer, so it is portable between employers. It is widely used in Europe and elsewhere, and some clients and jurisdictions in the region specify it. Many organisations hold personnel certified under both an employer-based scheme and ISO 9712 to satisfy different clients.
To decide on a route in practice:
- List the codes, client specifications and contracts that govern your NDT work.
- Record which certification route and edition each one references.
- Identify any conflicts or additional client requirements.
- Choose the route, or combination, that satisfies all of them for each person.
- Update your written practice or certification arrangements and brief your Level III.
A practical first step
Build a simple matrix of your current and target clients against the certification route each one requires, and compare it with how your personnel are certified today. Any mismatch is your priority. KARR's ASNT NDT Level III services can help you review the matrix and align your programme.
SNT-TC-1A, CP-189, NDT certification


