Contact
Home/Insights/

Non-Destructive Examination

Non-Destructive Examination

Guide

PAUT, TOFD or radiography? Choosing the right weld inspection

Radiography, conventional UT, PAUT and TOFD each find and size defects differently. Choosing well depends on defects, geometry, site impact and code acceptance.

November 4, 2026

4 min read

KARR technical team
PAUT, TOFD or radiography? Choosing the right weld inspection
At a glance
  • Radiography gives a clear permanent image and suits volumetric defects, but needs radiation controls that disrupt other work.
  • Conventional UT detects planar defects and locates reflectors in depth, though manual scans leave a limited permanent record.
  • PAUT records encoded scans across many angles, while TOFD is particularly strong at sizing flaw height.
  • The governing code and project specification decide which methods are permitted and how results are accepted.

Weld inspection decisions are often made by habit. Radiography was specified last time, so it is specified again. Yet the choice of method affects which defects you will find, how accurately you can size them, how long the inspection takes and how much the rest of the site is disrupted. For a new pipeline spread, a shutdown repair or an in-service vessel, the right answer may be different each time.

No single method is best for everything. Understanding what each one does well, and where it falls short, helps engineers specify inspection that is fit for purpose and acceptable under the governing code.

Radiography: a permanent picture

Radiographic testing passes X-rays or gamma rays through the weld and records the result on film or a digital detector. It produces an image that is easy to review and archive, and it is very good at showing volumetric defects such as porosity and slag inclusions. Inspectors and clients are familiar with it, and many specifications are written around it.

Its limitations are significant. Radiography is less reliable at detecting planar defects, such as cracks or lack of fusion, unless they are aligned with the beam. It gives little direct information about defect depth. Above all, it requires radiation safety controls: exclusion zones, barriers and often night shifts or area clearance, which can stop other work. On a busy plant or a congested offshore platform, that disruption carries a real cost.

Conventional ultrasonic testing

Manual ultrasonic testing sends sound pulses into the material and interprets the echoes. It needs no radiation controls, is portable and is well suited to detecting planar defects. It can also locate a reflector in depth, which radiography cannot do directly.

Conventional UT depends heavily on operator skill and, in its manual form, usually leaves a limited permanent record of the full scan. Results are harder for a third party to review afterwards, and coverage relies on the operator moving the probe correctly.

Phased array ultrasonic testing

PAUT uses a probe made of many small elements that can be fired in controlled sequences to steer and focus the beam. A single probe position can cover a range of angles, and scans can be encoded so that the full data set is recorded. The results can be reviewed, audited and stored, much like a radiograph.

PAUT is versatile and works on a wide range of weld geometries. It detects both volumetric and planar defects and provides good positional information. It does require careful setup, validated scan plans and qualified operators, and its performance depends on the reference blocks and procedures being right for the component.

Time of flight diffraction

TOFD uses a pair of probes on either side of the weld. Instead of relying mainly on reflected energy, it detects signals diffracted from the tips of a flaw. Because the timing of those signals is precise, TOFD is particularly strong at sizing the through-wall height of flaws, which matters greatly for fitness-for-service assessments.

TOFD has dead zones near the scanning surface and at the back wall, and it is less effective at characterising some defect types on its own. For this reason it is often combined with PAUT or conventional pulse-echo techniques to cover those zones.

Finding a defect and knowing how big it is are two different questions, and not every method answers both.

Choosing and combining methods

The choice depends on a handful of practical factors:

  • Detection versus sizing: if accurate flaw height is needed, TOFD or PAUT will usually be preferred over radiography.
  • Thickness and geometry: thin sections, small-bore pipe and complex nozzle welds may favour different techniques from thick, straight seams.
  • Material: coarse-grained materials and some austenitic welds are difficult for ultrasonics and may need specialised techniques.
  • Site disruption: ultrasonic methods allow other work to continue nearby, whereas radiography needs exclusion zones.
  • Code acceptance: the governing code, such as the relevant ASME section, and the project specification must permit the method and define its acceptance criteria.

Many codes now allow ultrasonic methods in place of radiography for certain applications, subject to conditions such as qualified procedures and personnel. Those conditions are set by the code and should be checked for each project rather than assumed. A sensible selection process looks like this:

  1. Identify the governing code, its edition and any client specification requirements.
  2. List the defect types of concern for the material, welding process and service.
  3. Decide whether detection alone is sufficient or whether accurate sizing is needed.
  4. Assess geometry, thickness, access and the impact of radiation controls on site.
  5. Select the method or combination, and qualify the procedure and personnel accordingly.

A practical first step

For your next inspection package, write down why each weld is specified for the method it has. Where the reason is simply that it was used last time, there may be a faster, safer or more informative option. KARR's NDE specialists can help you compare methods for a specific scope.

Topics

Weld inspection, PAUT, TOFD

From insight to site
Want this applied to your assets?
Talk to our team
Keep reading

More insights.

View all insights →