
- Reported dimensions are estimates within a stated tolerance, so assessments should allow for tool uncertainty.
- Prioritise anomalies systematically, flagging dents with metal loss and features at welds early.
- Verification digs across a range of features show how the tool performed on your line.
- Corrosion growth and remaining strength together should set the re-inspection interval, not habit.
An in-line inspection report can list thousands of features. For the engineer who receives it, the challenge is rarely a lack of data. It is deciding which handful of features need action now, which can be monitored, and which are simply the normal texture of a pipeline in service. Treating every listed feature as urgent is as unhelpful as filing the report and waiting for the next run.
Reading the report well means understanding what the tool can and cannot see, how certain each reported dimension is, and how the findings connect to a fitness-for-service assessment and a re-inspection plan.
What the report is telling you
Most reports group features by type. The main categories are:
- Metal loss: internal or external wall loss from corrosion, erosion or gouging, reported with depth, length, width and orientation.
- Dents: local deformation of the pipe wall, reported with depth and often flagged where they coincide with metal loss or welds.
- Ovality: out-of-roundness along a length of pipe, often from external loads, soil movement or construction.
- Manufacturing and weld features: laminations, mill anomalies and girth or seam weld indications, which may or may not be injurious.
- Reference features: valves, tees, bends, fittings and above-ground markers used to locate anomalies in the field.
The summary pages usually rank features by a calculated severity. That ranking is useful, but it reflects the vendor's assumptions about pressure, material and assessment method. Your own assessment should check those assumptions against actual operating conditions, material data and the line's threat history.
Tolerance and probability of detection
Every tool has a stated detection threshold, probability of detection and sizing tolerance, and these vary by feature type and dimension. A reported depth is not an exact measurement. It is a best estimate within a band, quoted at a confidence level. Small, shallow features near the detection threshold may be missed or undersized, and pinhole corrosion, narrow axial features and features near welds are harder to detect or size for some technologies.
The practical consequence is that assessments should use the reported dimension plus an allowance for tool tolerance, rather than the reported value alone. When a feature sits close to a repair threshold, that tolerance can be the difference between monitoring and digging.
An inspection report is an estimate with error bars, not a photograph of the pipe.
Prioritising anomalies
A sensible prioritisation works through the list in a structured way:
- Screen out clearly benign entries, such as reference features and shallow metal loss well below assessment thresholds.
- Flag anything the governing code or operator standard treats as needing prompt response, such as dents with metal loss or features at welds.
- Assess remaining metal loss for remaining strength at current operating pressure, applying tool tolerance.
- Estimate growth rates from previous inspections where available, or from conservative assumptions where not.
- Group features into immediate action, scheduled action and monitor, each with a date attached.
Verify in the field
Dig verification closes the loop between the tool and the pipe. Excavating selected features and measuring them with ultrasonic thickness, laser scanning or other direct methods shows whether the tool performed within its stated tolerance on your line. Choose verification digs to cover a range of feature types and depths, not only the worst ones, so that the results say something about the whole dataset. If field measurements differ systematically from reported values, raise it with the vendor and adjust the assessment before acting on the rest of the list.
Field work also adds information the tool cannot give: coating condition, soil conditions, signs of external interference and the true shape of complex corrosion.
From findings to fitness for service
Remaining strength calculations for corroded pipe are commonly based on methods such as ASME B31G and its modified forms, while broader fitness-for-service assessments, including dents and more complex damage, often draw on API 579-1/ASME FFS-1. The right method depends on the feature type, the material and the operator's integrity management framework. The output should be a defensible decision for each feature: no action, monitor, pressure reduction, repair or replacement.
The re-inspection interval follows from the same work. Corrosion growth rates, the size of the largest remaining features and the safety margins in the assessment together show how long the line can run before a feature is predicted to reach its limit. That date, with an appropriate margin, should set the next run, rather than a fixed calendar interval chosen out of habit.
A practical first step
When your next report arrives, ask the vendor for a short walkthrough of the tool performance specification and how it was applied, and plan a few verification digs before committing to the full repair programme. KARR's in-line inspection team can help with interpretation and field verification if additional support is useful.
In-line inspection, Anomaly assessment, Fitness for service


